Comments on: Two guys taking on clutch http://somebaseballnotes.com/2008/01/23/two-guys-taking-on-clutch/ Searching for truth behind the numbers of this great game Mon, 27 Apr 2009 20:57:15 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 By: What interested me online this week… « Baseball Notes http://somebaseballnotes.com/2008/01/23/two-guys-taking-on-clutch/#comment-3450 What interested me online this week… « Baseball Notes Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:25:25 +0000 http://somebaseballnotes.com/2008/01/23/two-guys-taking-on-clutch/#comment-3450 [...] mentioned this a few weeks ago, concerning Tom Tango asking fans to join him in a battle in the clutch debate where he will pit [...] [...] mentioned this a few weeks ago, concerning Tom Tango asking fans to join him in a battle in the clutch debate where he will pit [...]

]]>
By: Ryan Kirksey http://somebaseballnotes.com/2008/01/23/two-guys-taking-on-clutch/#comment-2169 Ryan Kirksey Thu, 24 Jan 2008 20:29:49 +0000 http://somebaseballnotes.com/2008/01/23/two-guys-taking-on-clutch/#comment-2169 Sorry, no FSU football here, Rob-o. And yes, there will be more math. But one more thing I should mention here about clutch that is often misunderstood. When comparing clutch, you can compare a lot of different things, the most well known being how did a player improve when they were in those clutch situations? And usually we are talking about a good to great player. But what about the .350 hitter who hits .333 in the clutch over a season? He is still better than almost all hitters in whatever clutch situation you are looking at, but his normal performance declined in the most pressure-filled situations. So it's all really on a sliding scale. If you want to compare players in the clutch make sure you are basing it on even ground, such as who improved more or declined less as a percentage to their normal performance throughout the season? Don't compare A-Rod to Adam Everett and without evidence say that A-Rod is the better clutch player if you look at his X compared to Everett's Y - A-rod's offensive skill level is far superior to Everett, everyone knows that. Grade them relative to how they go above or below their normal rates of production. Sorry, no FSU football here, Rob-o. And yes, there will be more math.

But one more thing I should mention here about clutch that is often misunderstood. When comparing clutch, you can compare a lot of different things, the most well known being how did a player improve when they were in those clutch situations? And usually we are talking about a good to great player.

But what about the .350 hitter who hits .333 in the clutch over a season? He is still better than almost all hitters in whatever clutch situation you are looking at, but his normal performance declined in the most pressure-filled situations. So it’s all really on a sliding scale.

If you want to compare players in the clutch make sure you are basing it on even ground, such as who improved more or declined less as a percentage to their normal performance throughout the season? Don’t compare A-Rod to Adam Everett and without evidence say that A-Rod is the better clutch player if you look at his X compared to Everett’s Y - A-rod’s offensive skill level is far superior to Everett, everyone knows that. Grade them relative to how they go above or below their normal rates of production.

]]>
By: Robert Frnklin Day Jr http://somebaseballnotes.com/2008/01/23/two-guys-taking-on-clutch/#comment-2164 Robert Frnklin Day Jr Thu, 24 Jan 2008 18:08:52 +0000 http://somebaseballnotes.com/2008/01/23/two-guys-taking-on-clutch/#comment-2164 Would you please write about Florida State football. And, please no mathematical logomethrimetrics. Would you please write about Florida State football. And, please no mathematical logomethrimetrics.

]]>